Bruno Fernandes may be delivering goals and assists for Manchester United, but two of the club’s former defenders believe his overall impact is more complicated than his statistics suggest.
Concerns were first raised by former United left-back Patrice Evra after Fernandes scored twice in the team’s 4–1 victory over Wolves on Monday. Speaking to Stake, Evra acknowledged the midfielder’s productivity but argued that his impressive numbers sometimes mask deeper issues in his play.
According to Evra, Fernandes often struggles to dictate the rhythm of the game or maintain positional discipline—qualities he feels are crucial for someone tasked with leading the team.
“Talking about Bruno is always delicate,” Evra said. “He scores goals and provides assists—those have never been the problem. The real concern is his ability to manage the tempo and offer structure. Half the time, you can’t even pinpoint his position because he’s everywhere. And when that happens, he’s not where he’s supposed to be. Still, without him, United wouldn’t be anywhere near their current spot in the league.”
Evra’s assessment feeds into an ongoing debate about Fernandes’ leadership as captain. While his influence in the final third is undeniable, critics argue that his emotional reactions and tendency to lose composure under pressure can affect the team negatively.
Former England defender Paul Parker offered an even sharper critique while speaking to Goal. He likened Fernandes’ constant roaming to the unpredictable movements of a toddler, highlighting how it leaves veteran midfielder Casemiro with too much defensive responsibility.
“Casemiro does a brilliant job,” Parker said. “But at United, he’s paired with someone who never stays put. Bruno is like my one-year-old—you can leave him in one place, look away for a moment, and he’s vanished.”
Parker added that Fernandes’ attacking contributions often overshadow the tactical imbalance he creates on the pitch.
“When he disappears from his position, he doesn’t exactly leave a note explaining where he’s gone,” Parker said. “Yes, he’ll pop up with a goal or an assist, and suddenly everything else is forgotten. But his constant drifting makes it hard for United to stay organised, especially in midfield.”
Both Evra and Parker agree that while Fernandes remains one of United’s most productive players, his lack of positional discipline and tendency to roam freely can undermine the team’s structure—an issue they believe must be addressed if the club hopes to regain consistency.
0 Comments